What is decentralisation? It’s a word that gets thrown around a lot in financial circles, and for good reason. When we think about things being centralised – from our data to our money, to even things as integral to our being as our identification – we think about an external source, some form of power, having control over it.
Centralisation, in some respects, allows for better regulation. Some people will argue that it’s in place as a concept to help keep things fair. However, as we’ve seen over the years, the world can be a very unfair place indeed.
The fact is, while everything is so ‘central’ focused, and so conglomerated, we don’t have as much power over our lives as we think we do. Not only that, but we deserve more power. There are some human rights in the world that we should never have to fight for.
However, this is the way society is, at least at present. We’re seeing some very interesting trends emerge when it comes to tokenisation. That is, the process of giving people the power to control their own money, their own income, their own contracts. Tokenisation is a term which generally applies in the technological sphere; however, I envisage it expanding to cover the human experience for the better in decades and centuries to come.
Therefore, let’s consider what tokenisation of people would actually mean. Would it create new jobs? Would it allow us to make money fairly, to gain access to education and resources without the need for privilege?
It is a dream that is not impossible. In a world where sports stars are tokenising their own contracts to ensure they stay in the driving seat, it’s not impossible to imagine us breaking free from multiple chains in the years to come.
How Does Tokenisation Work?
Tokenisation is not a finite concept. When we apply it to technology, we think about apps and services using bank details and card numbers to help us make payments. That’s in the simplest form. We also think about breaking down money into digital means, lines of code which we can mine autonomously.
Tokenisation, crucially, is about breaking down big data to make it more secure. Rather than leaving sensitive data and ID out in the open, we can create individual tokens which only we have authorisation or access to. This means that, ultimately, we have sole power of the data on each token.
Think of a token much like a human being, with access to its own brain. Only that human being has access to its inner thoughts and feelings. It is exclusivity on a biological scale. Tokenisation takes this biological concept and makes it actionable in wider society.
We’re already seeing tokens generated for security purposes. You might be granted a token to access specific services, or to use bank or credit cards. Tokens are small, yet mighty. They condense an awful lot of power into one simple concept, which means it’s not all that hard to imagine humanity benefitting from wider decentralisation.
That, however, is going to mean that there is a vast breaking down of establishment assets and resources. While not impossible, there are more than a few people – and big businesses – which stand in our way.
Why Are Things So ‘Centralised’?
In the type of society we live in, things are extremely centralised. It did not take us long as a species to realise that information, not knowledge, is power. Data sharing is worth a lot of money. What’s more, keeping fiat money and global finance centralised ensures that big business and world bankers get to keep their eyes on where we are as a society. The very idea that this power splits off and breaks away into individual, private chunks, is extremely scary to some people.
A key, modern example of centralisation which isn’t financial is the phenomenon of social media. While services such as Facebook and Instagram – both owned by Mark Zuckerberg – advise us that we have the power to move, edit and even delete our data from social spheres, we still do not have complete control. Facebook’s centralisation of user data from 2004 onwards became nothing short of a phenomenon. The rise of social media from the early to mid-00s made personal data a key commodity.
Big businesses – such as Facebook – were now able to centralise all kinds of information. This means that, each person who joined a social network would effectively be giving up their rights to the data they willingly shared. Social media has become such a part of everyday life that it is now integral not only to our social lives in general, but also in terms of how we run and grow our businesses.
Things are centralised because – as stated earlier – control means regulation. This is a hard argument to fight against when it’s clear that corruption runs rife across the globe. In favour of centralisation, there needs to be some form of oversight to ensure that smaller bodies – those beneath the regulators – are not ripping people off or are causing them harm.
However, everyday people, consumers, are still giving away a lot of power just to be regulated. Regulation might seem like a great idea, and something that’s both positive and necessary, however, it is keeping us all from retaining control over our data, our ID, and our lives.
Let’s think about it this way – would it be so bad if, instead of regulation, we had full control of everything we entered into?
You Don’t Have Full Control Over Your Life
It’s a sad fact, but you don’t. No one does. Consider who you rely on to look after your money, to entertain you, to deliver food to your door. Consider the games you play on your smartphone, the communications services you use, and the contracts you have to pour through to get to the ‘accept and continue’ button.
Contracts exist to set up a delegation of control. While many are innocent enough, legally binding contracts and writs exist to convince you to give up a little bit of your own control and power. Let’s not get ahead of things, however, as many contracts exist to protect interests.
Unfortunately, contracting exists not only to delegate and share power over an aspect of your life or experience, but also to ensure that there is trust in place. While most people will enter into things with pure intentions, history has told us time and time again that there is such a thing as a conflict of interest. There is also such a thing as greed, and mistrust. Not everyone is in it to win it all and step over everyone that gets in their way. However, it’s a shame that these processes exist purely to prevent greed and underhandedness going unpunished.
That said, while there are still contracts in the world, and while there is still widespread mistrust in society, there will never be major moves towards full decentralisation. Unfortunately, there are too many businesses and too many governments – corrupt or otherwise – who feel they stand to lose too much by sharing power. It’s true in some cases that scrapping contracts and decentralising everything might lead to some businesses struggling – but that doesn’t stop it from being an intriguing scenario we could all grow into.
How Could the Tokenisation of Humanity Work?
I believe that we are never going to see true decentralisation, a complete breaking apart of contracts and networks, until each and every person on the planet receives a token. This token would represent their wealth, their livelihood, their ID, their ability to say no. It would prevent scurrilous contracts from stealing data and money from unwitting signers. It would give people a fresh sense of power, and control – and in a world like this, the little control we can actively wrest is always going to be welcome.
So – in short, the widespread tokenisation of humanity would lead to a form of revolution. It’s not a million miles away from ideologies and thoughts put forward by socialists and communists. However, unlike failed attempts to bring communistic principles to the world – of which there are many – a complete tokenisation of the planet and of society would remove any kind of figurehead or controlling body.
We would each be in complete control of our own individual destinies. We would be able to see where our money goes and what it ultimately does. We would be able to freely invest time, money, and resources without the fear of losing anything precious, or wresting control.
This could be in the form of a digital token, or even a physical artefact. The wider potential for complete decentralisation will, if we follow the concept far enough, lead to a potential breakdown of societal norms as we know it.
Is Societal Breakdown a Good Thing?
The word ‘breakdown’ is often used in negative circumstances, so I’d like to avoid committing to a positive or a negative spin on the concept at this point. Instead, let’s consider tokenisation’ social reconstruction’, or perhaps ‘deconstruction’, if we were to apply the principles of Jacques Derrida to everyday life.
With tokenisation, and with individual power and control back in the hands of the individual citizen, it stands to reason that we would need to rethink government and politics completely. If we are to completely decentralise society, it would mean removing the need for a figurehead at the centre of it all. Implementing this would be tricky – and were we to travel far enough with this concept to work on a prototype scheme, we’d probably need to do a bit of wheel reinvention. But arguably, it would be worth it.
With individuals wresting control of their lives, they would, in theory, be able to keep hold of their human rights. They would be able to access services they wanted to access, do the things they wanted to do, and to pay for things they can reasonably afford. There would be no ties, and no one would be held to account.
It’s a utopian scenario. However, opponents to this strategy would likely point out that one of the issues we might face revolves around competition.
One Against Another
Tokenisation in its rawest form, as a concept on paper or on the screen, is ideal. It’s the best way to ensure that everyone is truly ‘free’. Let us imagine a scenario where atrocities such as Apartheid in South Africa, or the Holocaust in Nazi Germany, never happened. Both scenarios evolved as a result of overruling megalomania and ideology. Without such bodies applying their twisted regimes across all and sundry, there would, hypothetically, be no such scenarios that occur.
However, a key issue with tokenisation is that for one person to have human rights, another may need to infringe theirs. For everyone to live peacefully, there would need to be intrinsic agreements made between each person. There would need to be negotiation. This would potentially lead to a whole new kind of conflict.
This is where some pragmatists may suggest that there is a form of oversight – mediation of claims made through individual tokens, for example. However, as you are probably already noticing, this is starting to move us back towards the model we were striving to avoid in the first place.
Yes – hypothetically, regulation would resolve individual conflicts. But that would lead to wider regulation, and a delegated power source. That would lead to a rebuilding of a society which revolves around one central core.
Crucially, one way this could all play out is that humanity ends up back at square one, albeit with a strange, new system of tokens in place. However, that’s not to say making tokenisation work isn’t possible. It would need creative thinking and would effectively mean trying to resolve the human condition of greed, and the phenomenon of competition.
Law and Order
Opponents of a tokenisation system would argue that breaking away governments and bodies such as the police would result in outright chaos. However, as recent events around the world have shown us so far in 2020, there is never any guarantee that the people who are supposed to be protecting us, are doing so out of the kindness of their own hearts. Corruption exists everywhere, and it’s born out of greed and self-interest.
Therefore, for any kind of law and order to work in a post decentralised world, we would need to rethink the way that we communicate with one another. There would need to be a system of trust. We would need to ensure that we could trust one another – retaining control over ID, finance and other records would help to make things fiscally fluid, but it would mean that we would lose control in other ways.
A tokenisation of humanity could lead to a true distribution of wealth. By removing competition, it could lead to fair pricing, and that everyone would have access to money through fair work. However, there may not be any kind of concept of ‘work’ if competition, as a concept, is erased outright. This is where things start to get a little paradoxical.
Businesses, which employ millions of people, would need to make money without being competitive. It would mean that they would need to subsist and rely on their consumers to survive. This is true at the very base level of all business ownership, however, it’s safe to say that with competition, revenue is higher – and with that, businesses can grow, and people can become more comfortable.
However, we must also consider how law is going to persist in the long run through full decentralisation. There are, sadly, always going to be individuals who are wont to break laws, and to harm others. There are people who are willing to extort and to scam people out of their hard-earned money.
How will such matters be policed in an age with no police? The idea that people can police themselves and trust one another to be kind and to respect tokenised rights is idealistic – it is not a bad concept or one which is impossible by any means – but in a society which is replete with individuals who are selfish and who are willing to do harm unto others, decentralisation may seem like a fairly scary concept.
Can Tokenisation Ever Work?
Yes – in principle – though we may be some way away from building a model which is truly beneficial to all. As mentioned, outright human rights for everyone is a great concept – but there is always the risk that one person’s infringement is going to be someone else’s gain.
That’s why, while I believe that we will never experience full decentralisation until humanity is fully tokenised, there needs to be some form of balance in place. We must also consider that people are predisposed to look to others for thoughts and ideas. Even in a world where we break everything down and start again – tokenisation and individual power in its rawest form – there will always be leaders who emerge. There is a risk that the process will simply begin again, much in the same way that we built our first societies, leaderships and centralisation from the dawn of time.
This means that we must consider elements and areas of society which can feasibly benefit from tokenisation. As mentioned, we are already seeing plenty of decentralisation in the world of finance. It’s obvious not only in the world of financial security, but in terms of the cryptocurrency phenomenon, too. Cryptocurrency is by its very nature decentralised and is therefore, free from oversight. It is purely yours to do with as you wish.
This is a clear, actionable way to decentralise without outright chaos. Even though crypto trading has made millionaires out of people, there are still governments and bodies out there who are very hands-off when it comes to showing any kind of acceptance. This means, ultimately, that we are going to need to wait a while until it becomes widely adhered to all over the world. Some have even stated that crypto might even hold the key to a singular currency ideal. However, in a world of greed and corruption, cynicism sets in.
Fighting Against Cynicism
Of course, we must fight against cynicism if we are going to give the concept of tokenisation a fair trial. There are plenty of ideal scenarios and situations where tokenisation would help to ‘level the playing field’. For example, the ongoing squabbles over universal healthcare could be improved with a simple token system. It could help to save the stresses and strains that the NHS is under. By having access to our own private medical records, our finances, and any information the government or businesses may have on us, we may be able to start making happier, more profound choices in our daily lives.
Tokenisation is an astounding concept when you apply it wide across humanity. However, it is a concept which has a few practical concerns which will need to be fully discussed before any kind of system is rolled out. If we were to listen to cynics, once again, we could suggest that a world like this is never going to adapt to decentralisation as there will always be greed, competition, and jealousy in the world.
However, by taking a humanist approach – the belief that all people intrinsically want what’s best for society – it’s easier to see why tokenisation is such an appealing concept. However, even with a humanist approach, we would need to do all manner of untangling and restructuring of society for it to work feasibly in practice. This is no bad thing – but we would also need complete and utter investment.
Time will tell how far we will get with tokenisation and decentralisation in our own lifetimes. The future is very exciting – and maybe centuries from now, we will all have greater control over our individualities. For now, however, we must keep innovating in light of an incumbent societal order.